Review: An Age of License and Displacement by Lucy Knisley
I loved Lucy Knisley's memoirs French Milk and Relish but for some reason fell behind reading her newest travel memoirs, An Age of License and Displacement.
Her first two books were perfect for the foodie in me, and I was
looking forward to more of the same. Although Knisley's latest work is a
little less culinary focused, I still enjoyed the books.
An Age of License
documents Knisley's trip to a Norwegian comic con, and then her
continued travels to Sweden to see a guy she likes, to Germany to meet
up with friends, and finally to France to visit another friend and spend
a few days with her mother (who is traveling with friends).
Much
of the book is about Knisley's relationship with Henrik, a young man
she met in New York and then traveled with in Sweden and Germany and
then later in Paris. Knisley also talks about her insecurities at her
newfound fame in the comics world and her relationship with her mother
and her mother's friends in France.
The second book, Displacement,
is about a cruise she went on as a kind of chaperone to her aging
grandparents. Knisley is quite frank about her thoughts, frustrations,
and heartache when she discovers that her grands are sliding into
dementia. Juxtaposed throughout her travelogue are excerpts from her
grandfather's World War II diary, which she brought along hoping to use
it to prompt some conversation. Instead, Knisley gains a deeper
understanding of her grandfather and her own larger background.
In An Age of License,
Knisley is still a self-indulgent twenty-something, enjoying the last
days of freedom before settling down into her so-called real life. She
is transitioning between young adulthood to true adulthood, beginning to
gain a more mature outlook. In Displacement she sees some of the
harder aspects of old age, and her reactions seem very real and honest,
especially for a young woman still in her twenties.
The artwork in An Age of License is mostly black and white and in Knisley's trademark spare style with unbordered panels. Displacement
is in full color and the art is slightly more detailed, but it is still
recognizably Knisley. The excerpts from her grandfather's diary are in
sepia, which works well.
Although each of these books
can be read on their own, the arc of Lucy Knisley's maturation, both as a
graphic memoirist and as a person, is best understood by reading all
four books in order. Food lovers beware: food and eating are not the
focus of either of Knisley's latest work. I enjoyed An Age of License but thought Displacement to have the stronger emotional impact.
Twenty-somethings
may be able to relate more readily to Knisley's emotional turmoil than
older readers, but her artwork and openness have a wide appeal.
Published by Fantagraphics, 2014 and 2015
ISBN-13: 9781606997680 and 9781606998106
Source: Bought (see review policy)
Copyright © cbl for Beth Fish Reads, all rights reserved (see review policy)
8 comments:
I loved An Age of License and totally forgot about Displacement but, thanks to your post, I just put it on hold at the library.
I admit that Age of License was a bit of a disappointment to me after loving her first two, but Displacement totally made up for it.
I've never heard of these books, the artwork caught my eye on Bloglovin and I had to see what it was about. They sound awesome.I'm going to read them in order as you suggest.
I've been meaning to read those two. What a great idea to read them together to see how Knisley grows!
I LOVED Relish, so I haven't picked up this two latest books by the author. I should change that though. Thanks for writing about them.
thanks, these sound interesting ... putting them on my TBR list
Oh, I have so wanted to read these 2 latest additions to her work, but my library system doesn't have either yet. I may need to put in a special request :)
Thanks for the great reviews!
Sue
Book By Book
I had to revisit my mini-thoughts on Age of License and it turns out I enjoyed it (I did not like French Milk but LOVED Relish). I can definitely see how it would be interesting to read Age of License with Displacement. But you're right--there is something really interesting/fascinating watching Lucy as a person evolve throughout her books.
Post a Comment