Graphic Novels Challenge: Wrap Up
Yesterday I officially finished the Graphic Novels Challenge hosted by Laza. I am so glad she talked me into joining this challenge. I have been introduced to a whole new world of books. I am totally amazed at the scope of genres and artistic styles available in GN books. If you don't believe me, check out the challenge blog here.
I committed to a Major, which was 12 books. Here is my reading list. (Click on the author's name to see my review; my rating is in parentheses.)
1. The Demon of River Heights by Stefan Petrucha (B-)
2. Artemis Fowl by Eoin Colfer (A)
3. Bone 1 by Jeff Smith (B+)
4. Bone 2 by Jeff Smith (A+)
5. Bone 3 by Jeff Smith (A)
6. Bone 4 by Jeff Smith (A-)
7. Bone 5 by Jeff Smith (A)
8. Mouse Guard Fall 1152 by David Petersen (C)
9. Bone 6 by Jeff Smith (B+)
10. Bone 7 by Jeff Smith (B+)
11. Bone 8 by Jeff Smith (B+)
12. Bone 9 by Jeff Smith (B)
No question about it, I loved the Bone series. Some volumes were better than others, but none disappointed. Mouse Guard was a bit of a mystery to me because I thought I would be a fan. I am totally taken with the artwork, and I love a medieval setting. But the story and characters just didn't hook me. After having read Bone, Nancy Drew and Artemis Fowl both fall short in comparison. Yes, I gave Artemis an A rating, but that was only the second GN book I had ever read. What did I know? I'd probably give it a B- now.
I will be keeping up with the reviews posted on the challenge blog. That blog is shaping up to be an awesome resource for graphic novels. And I am now definitely a GN fan.
15 comments:
You finished fast! Well done! I have The Complete Bone on the April pile (is it sad that I already have an April pile? :P) and I'll come back and read your reviews more carefully then.
You have been on a roll! I am looking forward to some long stretches when working the Book Fair at the end of the month so I can read one or two (I know we always carry a couple on the shelves!)
Congratulations on finishing the challenge!
Oh my lord, I've only read 3/24. What am I going to do with myself *shame*
Nymeth and Sandy: you won't be disappointed!
Kathy (bermuda): I know you've just posted another review. I'll be over to read it soon.
Alea: no worries! It's only March!!
I've only read a few short ones and I'm totally not on track to finish, must read more!!!!
Good job - you finished this one quite quickly. I have to check out that Bone series.
Nely: I have to attempt to catch up to you!
Congrats on finishing the challenge! Glad you enjoyed them!
Yeah! Great job. I should give GNs a try. My boys tell me I would like them.
Congrats on finishing up! It's nice to have a new graphic novel fan. :)
I have never warmed up to graphic novels. Not that I tried that many of them. I remember I used to read Manga on my lunch break when I worked at Borders but gave up soon because they were just so simplistic. I think I just might have chosen the wrong ones to read.
Oh my gosh, you rock! I have only read one book for this challenge. Gotta get busy!
Congrats on finishing a whole challenge!! I've been seeing the Bone series around, but never really looked at it - I will now! Thanks!
Good for you for finishing the challenge! I'm going to look up the Nancy Drew one for my daughter.
Post a Comment